Tag: CPSC Recalls

  • Lead in Toys and Jewelry: Federal Limits, Recalls and How to Check

    Lead in Toys and Jewelry: Federal Limits, Recalls and How to Check

    Toys and children’s jewelry sold in the US must meet strict federal lead limits, but older, imported and online-marketplace items still turn up with too much lead. Under the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 (CPSIA), children’s products may contain no more than 100 parts per million (ppm) of lead in any accessible part, and no more than 90 ppm in paint or surface coatings.

    A parent sorting a box of children's toys on the sofa

    In short: the 100 ppm total-lead limit has applied to children’s products, meaning those designed mainly for children 12 and younger, since August 14, 2011; the 90 ppm paint limit since August 2009. Makers must have children’s products tested by a CPSC-accepted lab. The CDC advises not letting children play with toys made before 2009, being careful with imported and antique toys and toy jewelry, and checking CPSC recalls. Cheap metal jewelry is the classic danger: a child who swallows or mouths a lead charm can be seriously poisoned. Home swab tests are not reliable enough to clear a toy. If a child swallows a piece of jewelry or a small metal part, call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222, or 911 for severe symptoms.

    The federal limits

    The CPSIA tightened lead rules for children’s products in steps. The CPSC is the agency that enforces them.

    RuleLimitIn effect sinceApplies to
    Total lead content (substrate)100 ppm in any accessible partAugust 14, 2011 (after 600 ppm from February 2009 and 300 ppm from August 2009)Children’s products: designed or intended mainly for children 12 and younger
    Lead in paint and surface coatings90 ppm (0.009%)August 14, 2009Children’s products, certain furniture, household paint, toys and playground equipment for children 12 and under

    A few details that matter for parents:

    • “Accessible” parts. The 100 ppm limit applies to parts a child can touch or reach. Lead sealed inside a product where a child cannot reach it under normal use and abuse is treated differently.
    • Paint vs material. If a coating can be scraped off, the CPSC treats it as paint, subject to the 90 ppm limit; the material underneath must meet the 100 ppm limit.
    • Testing and certificates. Makers and importers of children’s products must have them tested by a CPSC-accepted third-party laboratory and issue a Children’s Product Certificate.
    • Exceptions. Some materials and items have exemptions or different limits, such as certain electronic components, metal parts of bicycles and ordinary books. Used children’s products sold second-hand are generally excluded from the total-lead limit, but that exclusion does not cover children’s metal jewelry.
    • Adult items. These limits are for children’s products. Jewelry and other items made for adults are not covered by the children’s lead limit, which is one reason the CDC warns about children handling adult jewelry.

    Why jewelry is the biggest worry

    Children’s metal jewelry has a long history of lead problems, and it is easy to swallow. The most serious case on record in the US came in 2006, when a 4-year-old in Minnesota died of lead poisoning after swallowing a heart-shaped charm from a bracelet given away with children’s shoes. The CDC’s report on the case led to a recall of 300,000 bracelets, and a CPSC document says the charm was 99.1% lead.

    It was not the first such case. A CDC report from 2009 notes that an earlier case, in Oregon in 2004, led to the recall of 150 million pieces of imported metal toy jewelry sold in vending machines. Today, children’s metal jewelry is singled out in federal rules: unlike most used children’s products, it stays subject to the 100 ppm limit even when sold second-hand.

    In 2016, the CDC described an infant in Connecticut who developed lead poisoning from wearing and mouthing a metal bracelet, and urged caregivers to be aware of the risk from handmade or adult metal jewelry.

    Recalls continue. In January 2025, the CPSC announced a recall of about 6,900 Yaomiao children’s jewelry sets sold only on Amazon from January 2022 to March 2024, because they contained lead above the federal limit and cadmium. The CPSC said to stop using the sets, keep them away from children and dispose of them for a refund.

    Which toys are higher risk

    The CDC says some toys, especially imported toys, antique toys and toy jewelry, may contain lead. Watch for:

    • Toys made before 2009. The CDC advises not letting children play with toys made before 2009, when the CPSIA’s tighter limits began to take effect. That includes hand-me-downs, garage-sale finds and heirlooms.
    • Painted metal or painted wood toys of unknown age or origin.
    • Cheap metal jewelry, charms, key chains and trinkets, especially from vending machines or unknown online sellers.
    • Adult jewelry and keys that babies and toddlers chew on.
    • Imported items from sellers that cannot show compliance with US rules.

    The CDC also suggests buying toys and children’s products made by major brands and sold at reputable retailers, which are more likely to meet the rules. Children’s cups and bottles have been recalled for accessible lead solder too; see lead in Stanley cups.

    How to check whether a toy or jewelry has been recalled

    1. Search CPSC.gov/Recalls. Search by product name, brand or type (for example “children’s jewelry lead”). Recall notices show photos, model numbers, where it was sold and the remedy.
    2. Check SaferProducts.gov. The CPSC’s public database lets you read and file reports about unsafe products. A CPSC spokesperson told TODAY in 2024 that each report is reviewed and can lead to a recall.
    3. Use the CDC’s recall list. The CDC keeps a page of recent lead-related recalls of children’s products, foods, cosmetics and medicines, with links to CPSC and FDA notices.
    4. Sign up for alerts. The CPSC offers email recall alerts. Keep order confirmations so you can match model numbers and claim a refund.
    5. Follow the remedy. Recall notices tell you to stop using the item and how to get a refund or replacement. Do not resell or donate recalled children’s products.

    Can you test toys or jewelry at home?

    Not reliably. A CPSC staff study in 2007 tested home lead kits on paints and other products and found 56 false negatives (lead was there, the kit missed it) and two false positives out of 104 results. The CPSC said consumers should not rely on these kits, that kits did not consistently detect lead under a non-lead coating, and that they are poorly suited to low concentrations. The current federal limits are very low (100 ppm and 90 ppm), and a swab cannot tell you whether a toy meets them.

    The EPA recognizes certain swab kits only for paint on wood, ferrous metal, drywall and plaster, not for toys or jewelry. If you need a real answer, a laboratory using X-ray fluorescence (XRF) or chemical analysis can measure lead content. For most families, the practical rule is simpler: if a toy or piece of jewelry is old, cheap metal, of unknown origin or recalled, take it away from the child. Our home lead test vs lab testing guide and lead test kits hub explain the options.

    Everyday steps for families

    • Keep metal jewelry, charms and keys away from babies and toddlers, and never let a child mouth them.
    • Store adult jewelry out of reach.
    • Wash children’s hands often and wash toys regularly, as the CDC advises; dust from old paint and soil can collect on toys.
    • Check hand-me-downs and second-hand finds against CPSC recalls; set aside anything made before 2009.
    • If a child swallows a piece of jewelry or a metal part, call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222 right away, or 911 if the child has trouble breathing, is vomiting repeatedly or has a seizure.
    • If a child has been mouthing a doubtful item for a while, ask the pediatrician about a blood lead test. Most children with lead in their blood show no obvious symptoms.

    More on lead in daily life is on our lead in household items hub, including pottery and dishes and cinnamon and spices. For health questions, see lead poisoning and lead and children.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the legal limit for lead in toys?

    Children’s products, those designed mainly for children 12 and younger, may contain no more than 100 ppm of total lead in any accessible part, and no more than 90 ppm in paint or surface coatings, under the CPSIA as enforced by the CPSC.

    Is lead in jewelry dangerous?

    It can be, especially for young children who mouth or swallow it. A child in Minnesota died in 2006 after swallowing a charm made almost entirely of lead. Keep metal jewelry away from small children and check CPSC recalls.

    Are old toys safe to give to children?

    The CDC advises not letting children play with toys made before 2009, when tighter federal lead limits began to take effect. Keep vintage toys for display.

    Do adult jewelry limits exist?

    The federal 100 ppm limit is for children’s products. Jewelry made for adults is not covered by that limit, which is why the CDC warns caregivers about children handling adult or handmade metal jewelry.

    What should I do with a recalled toy or piece of jewelry?

    Stop using it and keep it away from children right away. Follow the remedy in the CPSC notice, which is usually a refund or replacement from the company, and do not resell or give the item away.

    Does washing a toy remove lead?

    Washing removes dust and soil that collect on a toy’s surface, which is why the CDC recommends it. It does not remove lead that is part of the paint or the material itself.

    How do I report a toy I think has lead?

    File a report at SaferProducts.gov, the CPSC’s public database. If a child may have swallowed it, call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222 first.

  • Lead in Stanley Cups: What the Sealing Pellet Means for You

    Lead in Stanley Cups: What the Sealing Pellet Means for You

    Yes, many Stanley tumblers contain a small amount of lead, but not where your drink goes. Stanley says the lead is in a sealing pellet at the bottom of the vacuum-insulated wall, covered by a stainless steel cap, and that no lead is present on any surface that touches you or what you drink.

    A person inspecting the base of a tumbler

    In short: in January 2024, after viral videos of people testing their cups, Stanley confirmed it uses an “industry standard pellet” containing some lead to seal the vacuum insulation, covered by a durable stainless steel layer. Experts quoted by TODAY and NBC News said there is no exposure while that cover stays on; the concern is a damaged or missing base cap, especially around young children who might chew or mouth it. The CPSC has recalled several children’s insulated cups from other brands whose lead solder at the base was accessible. If a base cap has come off, keep the cup away from children and contact the maker.

    This guide reports what Stanley and the experts said at the time, and what the CPSC has done with similar products. It is not a lab result for any specific cup, and nobody we cite measured how much lead each pellet contains.

    What happened in 2024

    In January 2024, social media videos showed people swabbing the bottoms of Stanley tumblers with home lead test kits, some of which changed color. The tumblers were at the height of their popularity, and the posts spread quickly.

    Stanley’s parent company, Pacific Market International (PMI), responded with a statement that several news outlets published. In short, Stanley said:

    • Its manufacturing process uses an industry-standard pellet to seal the vacuum insulation at the base of its products, and the sealing material includes some lead.
    • Once sealed, the area is covered with a durable stainless steel layer that makes it inaccessible to consumers.
    • No lead is present on the surface of any Stanley product that comes into contact with the consumer or the contents of the product.
    • Its products meet all US regulatory requirements, including California’s Proposition 65, and it said its engineering and supply chain teams were making progress on alternative sealing materials.

    Stanley’s current support page repeats that the vacuum insulation is sealed with pellets that include some lead and are covered by a stainless steel layer, that no lead is on surfaces that touch the consumer or the drink, and that if the base cap comes off during ordinary use the product may be covered by its Lifetime Warranty.

    In February 2024, NBC News reported that a potential class action had been filed against PMI, alleging that the company had not disclosed the lead or warned about exposure if the seal is damaged. PMI said exposure potential was minimal. NBC did not report an outcome, and we have not confirmed one.

    Why insulated tumblers use a sealing pellet

    A vacuum-insulated tumbler has two stainless steel walls with the air pumped out between them. That vacuum is what keeps ice frozen for hours. To close the vacuum, makers seal a small opening, usually at the bottom of the outer wall, with a pellet or dot of sealing material, then cover it with a steel cap or plate.

    Stanley called its pellet an industry standard. CPSC recall notices show that other brands have used lead solder at the same spot, as we cover below. So the question for any insulated cup is not only whether it contains lead somewhere, but whether that lead can be reached.

    Is there a contact risk? What experts said

    An article published by TODAY on NBC News on January 24, 2024 asked several lead specialists. Their views, summarized:

    ExpertWhat they said
    Ronnie Levin, former EPA scientist, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public HealthIf the base barrier stays intact, there is no lead exposure and no risk from owning the cup. A single touch of exposed lead is unlikely to poison someone, but a child who mouths an exposed base could be contaminated.
    Jenna Forsyth, Stanford University School of MedicineTouching exposed lead once is low risk; swallowing lead is what matters most. Scraping the exposed spot on hard surfaces could flake off tiny pieces.
    Dr. Vicki Iannotti, pediatrician, Columbia UniversityRepeated exposure is the main worry, not a single incident.
    Paul Allwood, CDC lead poisoning prevention branchSpoke generally: even low lead levels once thought safe are now linked to harm. He did not comment on Stanley cups specifically.

    Other reporting from the same period quoted Jack Caravanos of New York University’s School of Global Public Health saying there is practically zero risk of ingesting the lead in the cup. Several experts added that they would still rather companies used no lead at all.

    The picture from these experts is consistent: an intact cup is not a lead source for your drink. A cup whose bottom cap has fallen off is a different story, because the sealing material may then be exposed where small hands and mouths can reach it.

    What the CPSC has done with similar cups

    Stanley tumblers are general-use products, not children’s products. Children’s products face the federal lead content limit of 100 parts per million in any accessible part. The CPSC has used that rule to recall several children’s insulated cups whose lead solder was accessible:

    • Green Sprouts toddler stainless steel bottles and cups (November 2022, about 10,500 units): the bottom base can break off, exposing a solder dot that contains lead. The firm had seven reports of bases breaking off and no injuries.
    • PandaEar stainless steel children’s cups (November 2023, about 1,600 units, sold on Amazon): an accessible solder bead on the bottom exterior had lead above the federal limit.
    • Klickpick Home stainless steel children’s cup sets (November 2023, about 3,600 units, sold on Amazon): same problem, an accessible solder bead on the bottom.
    • CUPKIN stainless steel children’s cups (July 2023, about 346,000 units): lead above the federal limit in the cups.

    A CPSC spokesperson told TODAY at the time that consumers can report lead concerns about any product at SaferProducts.gov, and that each report is reviewed.

    How to check your Stanley or any other insulated tumbler

    1. Look at the bottom. Most insulated cups have a steel cap or plate over the seal. If it is intact and firmly attached, the experts above said there is no exposure from the seal.
    2. If the cap is loose, dented or missing, stop letting children use or handle the cup. Do not pick at, scrape or file the exposed spot. Contact the maker; Stanley says a base cap that comes off in ordinary use may be covered by its warranty.
    3. Check recalls. Search the brand on CPSC.gov/Recalls, especially for children’s cups and sippy cups. The CDC’s list of lead-related recalls also includes stainless steel bottles and sippy cups.
    4. Choose children’s cups with care. For cups marketed to children, check the CPSC recall list and buy from sellers that can show compliance with the federal lead limits for children’s products.
    5. Be cautious with home swab tests. The bright-colored swabs people used in the videos are made for paint. The EPA recognizes certain kits only for paint on wood, ferrous metal, drywall and plaster. A CPSC staff study found home lead kits often gave false negatives and some false positives on paints and other products. A color change on a cup’s bottom does not tell you whether the drink is exposed. For a real answer about a specific product, you need a laboratory test, for example with an X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analyzer, the kind of instrument the CPSC uses; see home lead test vs lab testing.

    Should you worry if you have used one for years?

    If the base cap has always been in place, the experts quoted by TODAY said the cup was not exposing you to lead. If a cap came off and a child chewed or mouthed the base, or you are worried for any other reason, talk to your doctor or your child’s pediatrician; a blood lead test is the only way to know whether someone has been exposed. For urgent questions, call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222.

    Most lead exposure in the US still comes from familiar sources: old paint and dust, lead pipes, soil and certain imported products. Our lead and children page and the lead poisoning hub explain them. For other everyday items, see our lead in household items hub, including pottery and dishes, toys and jewelry and cinnamon and spices.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do Stanley cups have lead?

    Stanley says the sealing pellet at the base of its vacuum-insulated products includes some lead, covered by a stainless steel layer. It says no lead is on any surface that touches you or your drink.

    Can lead from a Stanley cup get into my drink?

    According to Stanley and the experts quoted in early 2024 coverage, no: the lead is outside the drinking chamber, under a steel cap on the outer wall. Exposure is only possible if that cap comes off and someone touches or mouths the seal.

    What should I do if the bottom of my Stanley cup fell off?

    Keep it away from children, do not scrape the exposed spot and contact Stanley, which says a base cap that comes off during ordinary use may be covered by its Lifetime Warranty.

    Are other tumbler brands lead-free?

    Some makers say their cups use lead-free seals; we have not verified individual brand claims. CPSC has recalled several children’s insulated cups whose lead solder at the base was accessible, so check the CPSC recall list for any cup a child uses.

    Can I test my cup with a home lead swab?

    You can, but the result will not tell you much. Swab kits are made for paint, and the CPSC has found home kits unreliable on other materials. A laboratory test is the only reliable way to measure lead in a specific product.